Is Christianity based on religion or relationship?
I recently started a sermon series on the Ten Commandments with my church. When I first had the idea, I wasn't completely sure that I wasn't insane. Some of the commandments seem so straightforward that it's difficult to flesh out an entire sermon on them. Others are dense, with layers that require a lot of explanation.
Beyond that, we tend to bristle at the idea of living by a set of religious rules. As Christians, we love to tell people, "It's not about rules or religion. It's about a relationship." We don't love the idea of relating to God simply through a set of regulations. So, spending ten weeks on the rules of honoring God doesn't always sit well with people. But the commandments are there for a reason, and they're still relevant for understanding how we're meant to live as followers of Christ.
So, is the claim that Christianity is just a relationship accurate? Yes, and no.
Healthy Relationships Have Rules
Our relationship with Jesus is foundational to the salvation we experience through him. He doesn’t ever just ask for our compliance. He desires obedience in the context of a relationship with us. Likewise, Israel's relationship with God is foundational to their salvation from the Egyptians in the Old Testament. He wanted to know them and wanted them to know him.
That said, any healthy relationship has rules. Holly and I have rules in our marriage. A good example: we’re not allowed to date other people. With our boys, we have rules that protect them and prepare them for the life ahead. Similarly, we all have rules that govern our relationships with our employers. We call them Employee Handbooks.
If I were to suddenly go on a date with another woman, I don’t think my wife would respond well if I told her, “Stop worrying. Our marriage is a relationship, not a set of rules." Similarly, I wouldn’t respond well if one of my sons broke our “no devices in the bedroom” rule and told me, “Dad, our relationship isn’t supposed to be about rules.” In both cases, the trust that sustains those relationships would erode.
Our Relationship with God Has Rules
So, it’s true that interacting with God is not about rules. Our foundation with him is built on a relationship. But all healthy relationships have rules and boundaries. They’re gifts that keep the relationship healthy and functioning.
Similarly, the law that God gives Israel in the Old Testament, along with the principles of Christian living spelled out in the New Testament, set boundaries that allow us to enjoy God's presence while respecting his holiness. They help us better understand him, what he values, and how we can reflect those qualities as his people. We see clearly what it means to honor him, and what breaks his heart.
Avoiding the Religion or Relationship Extremes
As in all things, the dynamics between religion and relationship in our spiritual lives requires balance and moderation.
On one hand, we don’t want to become so enmeshed in the relational aspect to God that we violate the boundaries he has given us. When one party in a relationship violates well-established boundaries, that relationship will suffer. Similarly, we can’t expect our relationship with God to flourish when we ignore the boundaries he has put in place for us. He gives us his grace, but that grace is not a license to sin.
On the other hand, when we become overly enmeshed in the rules behind our interactions with God, we can slip into blind legalism. Suddenly, we’re trying to earn a position with the Lord that has already been earned on our behalf. We begin to treat relating to him like a formula that, once perfected, gets us whatever we want from him.
So, is it about religion or relationship? In all honesty, it’s both. We must appreciate both aspects of the Christian faith, without placing undue emphasis on either one. Rules without relationship just leads to legalism. Relationship without rules just leads to lawlessness and cheap grace. But a healthy relationship with God founded on his unmerited favor, that respects the boundaries he has placed before us, leads to a life of flourishing in him.



