A church with only healthy, mature members is neither healthy nor mature. Are we making enough room for those who have obvious gaps in their growth?

This past year has been a whirlwind. After years of serving in a variety of congregations, my passion for church revitalization brought me to Valwood Park Baptist Church. For a while now, I have known that God was calling me to lead a declining congregation back to a place of health. I didn't accept the job despite our church's current state, but  because of it.

Since my arrival, I've been developing a close friendship with one of our newest members. We frequently grab coffee, talk through issues, and often marvel together at what God is doing among us. After one of our heavier conversations, he sent me a text message that brought a smile to my face.

"I feel like this church is a place where I can be growing without already having to be grown."

The Desire for Maturity in Our Churches

As pastors, we carry a heavy burden to faithfully and diligently shepherd those under our care. We want to feed our people with the Word of God in all its fullness. In 1 Peter 5, we are called to humbly, cheerfully, and eagerly care for the flock until the Chief Shepherd, Jesus, appears. Any good pastor desires to see his people grow in maturity. We would be alarmed to look across the room and see a spiritually immature, anemic congregation. But in our desire to push our churches to greater spiritual depth, we must also be aware of an opposite danger.

The Alarming Indicator

In a recent seminar I attended, Sam Rainer made a claim that continues to stick with me. He challenged us,

"A church that has only mature believers is neither healthy nor mature."

As shocking as this claim seems on the surface, he is right. If a church has reached a place where every member is mature, where everyone seems to be in theological lockstep, and where there is no drama, it has also likely lost its sense of mission.

Historically, gospel advancement in the Church has always led to theological tension. Among the earliest Christians, every time the gospel moved into a new culture, new questions would arise concerning how it should appropriately contextualize. New people entering the fellowship would always bring fresh ideas and new challenges. The questions and tensions often led to church councils where leaders sought clarity and biblical fidelity.

The global Church has always been messiest when it's been the most missional. This same principle extends to the local church as well. New believers don't show up at your doorstep fully grown and mature. Those who have struggled with their faith for years don't walk through the door with their issues sorted out. If a church only has room for those who are (seemingly) already mature, they don't have room for those who are in the earlier stages of their maturity.

This means that a church which is gospel-centered, theologically-guarded, and missions-focused, will naturally be messy. It will include people with hidden addictions, rough edges, self-taught (and strange) theological ideas, and broken marriages. But if the church is also committed to lifelong discipleship, those same people will rub against, and benefit from, those who devour systematic textbooks, enjoy church history, and thrive on rich Christian community.

Get Comfortable with Messy

Healthy churches embrace the messy. Stagnant and declining churches fight to keep the more mature believers while ignoring the difficult ones until they quietly leave. If you're truly serving as a gospel outpost in your community, you will have guests and members who fit in nearly every stage of your discipleship pipeline. You will naturally have those who enjoy arguing about Calvinism vs. Arminianism sitting next to those who are checking the table of contents to find the book of Isaiah in their Bibles before the sermon.

There should be genuine love and appreciation in your ministry for both. There should be room in your church for both. There should be a seat at the fellowship table for both. Just as you would be alarmed if there is a lack of maturity in your congregation, you should be alarmed if there is a lack of immaturity as well.